Frequently Asked Questions
How many colors should I use on a Craftsman exterior?
Three to five. The main siding gets the body color. Window and door trim gets a second color. The front door and possibly window sash get an accent color. If the home has a secondary shingle band in the gable, that often gets a slightly different shade from the main siding. Each surface having its own color is what gives a Craftsman its visual depth.
Should I paint the rafter tails on my Craftsman?
No, if they are natural wood in good condition. Exposed rafter tails, knee braces, and porch beams are signature Craftsman details meant to show wood grain. Use a semi-transparent stain rather than paint. If previous owners already painted them, you can either strip back to bare wood or apply a solid stain in a warm brown tone.
Can I paint my Craftsman white?
You can, but pure white siding does not match the architectural tradition. Original Craftsman homes used warm, earthy tones. If you want a light exterior, choose cream, putty, warm ivory, or a light warm gray instead of bright white. These options honor the style while keeping the home feeling light and fresh.
How often should I repaint my Craftsman exterior in Oakland?
Most Craftsman exteriors in Oakland last 7 to 10 years between repaints, depending on sun exposure, moisture, and the quality of the previous paint job. Homes in the hills with heavy sun may need repainting closer to 7 years. Homes with fog exposure may see mildew buildup that requires attention even if the paint itself is holding. For more detail, see our post on how long exterior paint lasts in the Bay Area.
Do you help with color selection?
Yes. Color consultation is part of every exterior painting estimate from Integrity Paint. We bring paint samples, discuss options based on your home’s style and neighborhood, and apply test patches so you can see colors on your actual surfaces before committing.